AFP Files (Le) Copyright Infringement Suit Against Google
Google News, one of the more recent additions to the Google family of specialty sites has been sued in the District of Columbia by Agence France Presse (AFP), the French equivalent of the Associated Press. In the suit, AFP claims that Google News is “reproducing and publicly displaying AFP’s photographs, headlines, and story leads on Defendant’s news aggregation Web site.” In addtion, the suit claims that Google also is stripping from the lead stories AFP’s copyright information.
Pivotal to this case will be the question of whether — in the new digital age — publishers of content have any duties beyond those noted in the Copyright Act to keep information on their web sites from being indexed by news web crawlers, like the ones at Google. According to Google, technology is available to block the web crawlers used by Google. AFP claims that a copyright statement is sufficient to ward off would-be infringers, and that it has not responsibility to purchase technology to keep out Google.
Other issues that will no doubt come up in the case include whether the headlines that Google is taking constitute the heart of AFP’s creative authorship. On the one hand, headlines typically constitute only a few words compared to the total article. On the other, many copy editors work very carefully to craft headlines that will attract the reader and accordingly, can come up with some unique presentations. Then again, many news organizations use a technology called Real Simple Syndication, which automatically pushes headlines to users. Such widespread use of this type of technology suggests that the market for purchasing the article may not be depleted by the taking of the headlines.
One hopes that Google’s litigation budget is not yet maxxed out. Google also recently launched a service called Google Books. According to Internetnews.com, Google Books indexes the content entire books such that a search query might trigger a quote from one of them. Shakespeare, perhaps or other books in the public domain may be fair game; still, wethinks we smell something smouldering.